Previous article Next article

See translation in english US and EC Oligopoly Control

US and EC Oligopoly Control

Sigrid Stroux

Cette rubrique Livres recense et commente les ouvrages et autres publications en droit de la concurrence, droit & économie de la concurrence et en droit de la régulation. Une telle recension ne peut par nature être exhaustive et se limite donc à présenter quelques publications récentes dans ces matières. Auteurs et éditeurs peuvent envoyer les ouvrages à l’intention du responsable de cette rubrique : catherine.prieto@univ-paris1.fr.

When major suppliers independently (or otherwise) perceive that they can collectively control the market price of a product, is it collusion ? Not necessarily. Yet for consumers this ’interdependent pricing’ variously called tacit collusion, or conscious parallellism, is experienced precisely as collusion would be experienced. This kind of oligopolistic market distortion, though clearly illegal in the intent of all antitrust and competition law, and just as clearly rampant in today’s globalised trading system, usually succeeds in evading existing legislation. Antitrust authorities encounter great difficulties coping with such markets. Can this situation be remedied ? Here is a deeply researched and very detailed book that explores, as thoroughly as has ever been done whether competition law can combat oligopolistic markets. Drawing on the two bodies of law ’U.S. and EC’ that offer the widest range of experience, US and EC Oligopoly Control assesses whether, by the rule of law, the destructive economic trend that is becoming more and more characteristic of today’s global economy can be countered by means of applying the core competition provisions. Among the crucial legal concepts examined in the book in depth are the following :

abuse of a collective dominant position ; facilitating practices ; substantial lessening of competition ; and non-coordinated unilateral effects. In a brilliantly original discourse, Stroux also confronts the possibility of preventing anticompetitive oligopolistic markets from coming into existence. The focus here is on merger control, and on how the core provisions of EC competition law can be construed to make, in the words of J.K. Galbraith, ’satisfactory contact with olipology.’

Any practitioner, policymaker, or academic in the field of competition law could hardly ask for a more thoroughly documented work. EC and U.S. antitrust law is examined, and dozens of court decisions are quoted, with complete citations throughout. The book is a gold mine for anyone interested in the important task of extending the reach of competition law and antitrust law in this era of globalization. In this comprehensive work the author deals with the application of the core competition provisions, both in the US and the EU, to oligopolistic markets which function anti-competitively. Stroux’s thorough analysis of the subject-matter and accessible writing style, based on a solid structure, make the book a valuable guide for practitioners and scholars.

Author

Quotation

Sigrid Stroux, US and EC Oligopoly Control, December 2004, Concurrences N° 1-2004, Art. N° 110509

Publisher Wolters Kluwer

Date 16 August 2004

Number of pages 269

ISBN 9789041122964

Visites 55

All reviews